Example 1of US patent 3,932,384 awarded to Sawa et al. reads:
“The resulting crude base (17.4 g) is passed through a column of 87 g of silica gel and eluted with benzene to yield the pure base (15.58 g) which on recrystallisation from an azeotropic mix of benzene/n-hexane affords 15.64 g (93.2%) of 6-benzyl-3,4-dimethoxy-10,11-methylenedioxy-5,6,7,8,13,14-hexahydrodibenz[c,g]azecine….”#
# There must be some error in their yield calculation
In 2009, when I searched, this was the only recorded example of recrystallisation from an azeotrope, with the exceptions of those using the commercially available azeotropes between water any one of ethanol, hydrogen chloride, or hydrogen bromide.
In a previous blog article, {https://kilomentor.blogspot.com/search?q=azeotropes#google_vignette}, KiloMentor proposed six azeotropes that might usefully serve as recrystallising solvents. Here, I want to look at a broader combination of common solvent possibilities.
In a binary lower-boiling azeotrope, each component of the solvent mixture reduces the cohesion of the molecules of the other component. As a result, the vapour pressure of the azeotropic mixture is greater than the sum of the partial vapour pressures of the components added together. Each component is repelling the other into the vapour above the mixed liquid itself. Consequently, the combined vapour pressures match atmospheric pressure at a lower temperature than either component boiling separately.
If a binary mixture of solvents with the composition of a lower-boiling azeotrope were used to dissolve a practical amount of an essentially nonvolatile solute, such as would be required in a recrystallisation, and the mixture refluxed, the azeotropic mix of solvents might not distil over. The azeotrope might ‘break’.
The solute is likely, to some extent, to disrupt the original vapour-liquid equilibrium (VLE). A soluble solute will theoretically always alter the relative volatilities of the two original components due to intermolecular interactions that differ between each solvent component and the solute. This will cause the composition of the refluxing vapor to no longer be identical to that of the liquid at the original azeotropic point. But this should make only a minute difference in the liquid composition since the refluxing vapour is such a small proportion of the solvent mixture.
Indeed, some nonvolatile solute will cause the relative volatility between the two original components to become so large that the azeotrope breaks.This is inconsequential when under total reflux conditions no liquid is being distilled. However, a mixture of a solute dissolved in an excess of a lower boiling azeotropic composition cannot be concentrated without risking a change in solvent composition.
There is a greater concern. Some combinations of solute with an amount of a lower-boiling binary azeotropic mixture of solvents in amounts practical for recrystallization may cause the liquid to separate into two phases. This could arise if there is enough solute with an overwhelming preference for interacting with one of the two solvent components. Although phase separation may not occur when hot, the solute may oil out in a phase with predominantly one of the azeotrope’s components upon cooling.
despite these risks, one may be able to predict situations where a substrate has a structure that is likely to work advantageously during recrystallization with a low-boiling azeotropic mixture of solvents. A compound that has one portion of its structure that is preferentially solvated by one component of the azeotrope and another domain preferentially solvated by the second component is unlikely to cause phase separation. Furthermore, because a greater weight per volume of an amphiphilic substrate should be soluble in a lower-boiling azeotrope than in the same volume of either of its pure components, a better recovery of crystalline solute might be expected upon strongly cooling it.
Notice that such a recrystallization differs little from ordinary recrystallization from a two component solvent mixture. There is the advantage that the azeotropic composition is better controlled than using a mechanical mixture. Yet a disadvantage is that for the mechanical mixture, all proportions of the two pure solvents are available.
Many potential solutes have apolar and polar/hydrophilic and hydrophilic domains within their complete structure, and it is these that are more likely to be usefully recrystallized from lower-boiling binary azeotropic mixtures of common organic solvents. Those listed below might be particularly attractive for a solute that finite but insufficient solubility in each solvent separately:
Azeotropic Solvent Mixture b.p.
5% ethanol in dichloromethane 39.0
7% methanol in dichloromethane 37.8
3% methanol in MTBE 52.6
31% water in MTBE 51.3
33% cyclohexane in acetone 53.0
41% hexane in acetone 49.8
12% methanol in acetone 55.7
7% ethanol in chloroform 59.4
13% methanol in chloroform 53.5
31% THF in methanol 60.7
20% isopropanol in methanol 64.0
46% hexane in THF 63.0
3% 1-butanol in hexane 67.0
4% allyl alcohol in hexane 65.7
22% 2-propanol in hexane 61.0
21% ethanol in hexane 58.7
23% isopropyl alcohol in ethyl acetate 74.8
31% ethanol in ethyl acetate 71.8
49% methanol in ethyl acetate 62.1
28% toluene in ethanol 76.7
30% isopropanol in 2-butanone 77.3
34% ethanol in 2-butanone 74.8
33% 2-propanol in cyclohexane 68.6
2% acetic acid in cyclohexane 79.7
31% ethanol in cyclohexane 64.9
33% 2-propanol in cyclohexane 68.6
42% toluene in isopropanol 80.6
12% water in isopropanol 80.4
28% acetic acid in toluene 105.4
Finally, some binary azeotropes show particularly large deviations from ideal behaviour. That is, their mixtures show the largest boiling point depression. These, quite possibly, could dissolve significantly more of an amphiphilic solute and might give a higher recovery on cooling than other choices.
Selected Azeotropes with Big Bp Depressions
!st Solvent (bp) 2nd Solvent (bp) Az. bp. Dep.
Cyclohexane(81) Isopropanol (82) [67] 14
Cyclohexane (81) Ethanol (78) [65] 13
1-Chlorobutane( 78) Ethanol (78) [66] 12
2-Chlorobutane(69) Methanol (65) [53] 12
Ethanol (78) Hexane (69) [59] 10
Hexane (69) Isopropanol (82) [61] 8
Chloroform (61) Methanol (65) [54] 7
Hexane(69) Nitromethane (101) [62] 7
Acetonitrile (82) Isopropylether (67) [62] 5
t-Butanol (83) Hexane (69) [64] 5
1,2-Dichloroethane(83) Methanol (65) [60] 5
Hexane (69) 2-Butanone (80) [64] 5
Selection Criteria
- Greater than 10% of the minor component
- Azeotrope bp. <70 C
- 5 Cº degrees or more difference between the lower boiling component and the azeotrope